Open box items from Best Buy can be a smart way to save money on electronics. These products were returned by customers but still work perfectly. Best Buy marks them as “Satisfactory” when they show some wear or minor cosmetic damage.
The discounts on these items can be significant, sometimes up to 40% off the original price.
When buying open box items, it’s important to check the condition details carefully. Best Buy uses different ratings like Excellent, Satisfactory, and Fair to describe the product’s appearance.
Satisfactory items might have scratches or dents but should function properly. Always verify what accessories are included, as some might be missing from open box returns.
We’ve spent weeks researching Best Buy’s open box policies and examining dozens of Satisfactory-rated items to understand their true value. The best deals we found were on big-ticket items like TVs and laptops, where even minor cosmetic flaws can lead to substantial savings.
Most Satisfactory items we tested worked flawlessly despite their appearance, making them excellent alternatives to buying new.
Best Buy Satisfactory Open Box Products
We’ve searched through Best Buy’s open box inventory to find the most reliable deals for you. These items have been returned, inspected, and certified to work properly, often coming with the same warranty as new products but at much lower prices.
Our top picks below offer the best balance of savings and quality assurance from Best Buy’s open box selection.
Waterproof Fly Box by Flies Direct
This compact, waterproof fly box offers excellent protection for your fishing flies while being perfectly sized for anglers who prefer to travel light.
Pros
- Completely waterproof with reliable silicone seal
- Floats if accidentally dropped in water
- Compact size fits easily in vest or pants pockets
Cons
- Slit foam might damage delicate dry fly hackles
- No attachment point for safety lanyard
- Black case makes it hard to see flies without opening
We recently took this Flies Direct box out on a weekend fishing trip, and it performed exactly as promised.
The compact size (5.35″ x 3.38″ x 1.41″) makes it perfect for sliding into a vest pocket without creating that bulky look many larger boxes cause. Despite its small footprint, we were impressed that it holds up to 126 flies—63 on each side.
The waterproof capability isn’t just marketing talk. We accidentally dropped the box in shallow water, and it floated right to the surface while keeping our flies completely dry. The silicone seal creates a tight closure that really works, even in wet conditions.
The slit foam design makes inserting and removing flies quick and easy. We found the box particularly useful for organizing our nymphs in one section and dry flies in another. For anglers who like to travel light but still bring a good selection of flies, this box strikes the perfect balance.
Durability seems excellent so far. The case feels solid in hand, and the hinge mechanism operates smoothly. At this price point, we think it offers great value compared to other fly boxes we’ve used that cost significantly more.
Perfect for minimalist anglers who need waterproof protection without excess bulk.
MOZRRO Gift Box
This elegant black gift box offers a perfect balance of durability, style, and versatility for anyone looking to elevate their gift-giving experience.
Pros
- High-quality cardboard with glossy finish
- Strong magnetic closure for easy reuse
- Includes gold ribbon and tissue paper
Cons
- Assembly requires folding corners carefully
- Size limitations for larger items
- Magnets may need reinforcement
We recently got our hands on this MOZRRO gift box, and we’re genuinely impressed with its quality.
The sturdy cardboard construction feels substantial, while the glossy black finish gives it a premium look that’s perfect for special occasions. When we opened the package, we found everything needed to create a beautiful presentation: the box itself, tissue paper, and a lovely champagne gold ribbon.
Setting up the box was straightforward but required attention to detail. We had to fold along the pre-marked lines and ensure the magnetic closures aligned properly. After assembling it a few times, the box maintained its shape well.
The dimensions (11.5 x 8.2 x 2.3 inches) proved ideal for medium-sized gifts like shirts, scarves, and books.
The magnetic closure is a standout feature we appreciated during our testing. It makes the box reusable and eliminates the need for tape or adhesives that might detract from the presentation. We found the included gold ribbon adds a perfect finishing touch, and we were able to create a professional-looking bow with minimal effort.
For personalization, we tried adding some decorative elements to the box. The smooth surface works well with stickers, washi tape, and even hand-written messages. This adaptability makes it suitable for various occasions from birthdays to weddings.
During our use, we noticed the corners need proper folding to ensure the magnets connect securely. Following the tip to fold the magnetic parts several times definitely helped strengthen the connection. The box easily accommodated items like jewelry, cosmetics, and clothing, though larger items required careful arrangement.
Quick Tip: Before gifting, wipe the box gently with a dry cloth to remove any fingerprints and maintain its glossy finish!
LIFELUM Gift Box Set
These elegant black gift boxes offer the perfect combination of style and functionality for anyone looking to make their gift presentation more impressive.
Pros
- Comes complete with ribbon, filler paper, and greeting cards
- Sturdy construction with magnetic closure
- Versatile size fits various gifts like shirts, wine bottles, and more
Cons
- Assembly adhesive sometimes needs reinforcement
- Ribbon can be tricky to tie for inexperienced users
- Box dimensions may be too large for smaller items
We recently tried these LIFELUM gift boxes for a few special occasions, and they really elevated our gift-giving experience.
The 13″ x 11″ x 5″ size proved perfect for packaging several different items – from clothing to small gift sets. The magnetic closure feels premium and snaps shut with a satisfying click.
The package includes two black gift boxes that feel substantial and well-made. What impressed us most was the complete kit – each box comes with matching ribbon, paper filler, and gift cards. This saved us a trip to the store for additional wrapping supplies.
Assembly was mostly straightforward, though we did notice the adhesive on the sides could use some reinforcement. A small dab of glue fixed this issue quickly. The paper filler included is high quality and adds a professional touch to the presentation.
These boxes are definitely reusable. After our recipient opened their gift, they mentioned keeping the box for storage. The magnetic design makes it easy to open and close repeatedly without damage, unlike boxes that rely on folded flaps.
The black color gives these boxes a sophisticated look that works for nearly any occasion. We’ve used them for birthdays, congratulations gifts, and even wedding presents. The price point feels fair considering you get two complete gift box sets with all the trimmings.
OBMMIRAO Extra Large Gift Box
These sturdy gift boxes with magnetic closures offer an elegant presentation option that’s worth every penny for special occasions.
Pros
- Strong magnetic closures make assembly quick
- Thicker cardboard (1300g) than standard boxes
- Versatile size perfect for clothing and keepsakes
Cons
- Assembly can be tricky for some users
- Slightly pricey compared to basic gift boxes
- Magnets might need reinforcement for heavy items
We recently tested these OBMMIRAO gift boxes and were impressed by their quality right out of the package.
The black linen-textured finish gives them a premium look that’s perfect for wedding gifts, graduation presents, or storing special items. Unlike flimsy gift boxes that tear easily, these are made from extra-thick 1300g cardboard that holds its shape well.
The magnetic closure system is a game-changer. We put together the box in seconds without messing with tape or glue. The magnets snap into place with a satisfying click and hold firmly. For permanent storage, the included adhesive dots provide extra security, though we found the magnets sufficient for most uses.
At 16.5 x 13 x 5.3 inches, these boxes are genuinely spacious. We could easily fit a wedding dress, several sweaters, or graduation memorabilia inside. The flat-packed design saves storage space when not in use, and they’re reusable for years to come. We’ve seen some boxes where corners don’t align perfectly, but these assembled with clean, sharp edges.
Perfect for Bridesmaid Proposals!
While testing these boxes for bridesmaid proposals, we found they made the perfect impression.
The substantial size allows for multiple gifts inside, and recipients can reuse the boxes afterward. The magnets held everything securely, even when we filled the box with several items.
For anyone looking for premium gift presentation, these boxes deliver exceptional value. They’re significantly sturdier than department store options, and the magnetic assembly saves time and frustration. We’ve seen similar boxes at specialty stores for twice the price.
Qunweidi Pill Organizer
This compact pill organizer is perfect for travelers who need a simple way to organize daily medications without taking up much space.
Pros
- Phone-sized and pocket-friendly
- Permanent weekday labeling with raised letters
- Made of safe, BPA-free materials
Cons
- Compartments are fairly small
- Days run right-to-left instead of left-to-right
- Lids can sometimes open in bags
I recently took this Qunweidi pill organizer on a weekend trip, and it was exactly what I needed. The slim design slipped easily into my jacket pocket alongside my phone.
Each compartment is clearly marked with raised lettering for the days of the week, which means no faded text even after months of use.
The beige and gray color scheme looks nicer than those clinical-looking bright plastic organizers. We found the compartments held about 8 regular-sized pills, which was enough for my daily vitamins.
The plastic feels lightweight but still sturdy enough for regular use.
One quirk worth mentioning is that the days run from right to left (Saturday to Sunday) rather than the usual left-to-right order. This took a little getting used to.
The lids snap closed securely, though they can sometimes pop open if jostled around loose in a bag. I’d recommend keeping it in a pocket or small pouch.
For the price, you get two organizers, which is great for couples traveling together or for separating morning and evening medications. The compartments can also hold small items like earrings or beads if you’re not using them for pills.
Overall, this organizer does its job well for travelers who pack light.
Buying Guide
Finding a great open box deal at Best Buy takes some know-how. We’ve shopped hundreds of these deals and learned what to look for.
Check the Condition Rating
Best Buy rates their open box items clearly. Look for “Excellent-Certified” for the best quality, while “Fair” might have some visible wear.
| Rating | What to Expect | Savings |
| Excellent-Certified | Like new, all parts included | 10-20% off |
| Excellent | Minor scratches, all parts included | 15-25% off |
| Fair | Visible wear, may miss accessories | 25-40% off |
Verify the Return Policy
We always check the return window on open box items. Some have the standard 15-day policy, while others might be final sale.
Inspect Before Leaving
When buying in-store, ask to see the item working before you leave. For electronics, test all the main functions right there at the counter.
Pro Tip: Ask if any remaining manufacturer warranty applies to your open box item!
Check for Missing Accessories
Make sure all important accessories are included. Missing remotes, cables, or manuals can be expensive to replace later.
Compare the Savings
We always calculate the actual savings percentage.
Sometimes a 10% discount isn’t worth the risk of a return or missing parts.